Post by Master-9 on May 4, 2004 20:28:51 GMT -5
April 23, 2004
Court Restitution
9:30AM - Chief Black Thunderbird “Eagle” escorted into courtroom.
9:35AM - Judge C. Ashley Royal enters and court comes to order.
(Keep in mind these notes are shorthand formatted and not word for word verbatim conversations. Thank you.)
Judge - Are you all ready for proceeding? (To lawyers)
Lawyers - Yes your honor.
(Government prepare)
Moultrie - My witness has one exhibit.
Judge - Asked defense if they seen exhibit.
Defense - They answered yes.
Moultrie - Review Dr. Elliott’s credentials and expertise regarding physical, mental and _____ abuse.
Defense - Clarification of credentials.
Moultrie - Psychiatry in diagnosis of physical, mental and ______ abuse.
(Preparation)
Judge - Are you going to have one witness?
Moultrie - Yes.
As we wait. Discussing with court regarding witness assumption. That they are not witnesses. Interest bearing account will be set up. Fruitless to state what happened at trial regarding witness.
Defense - Witnesses testimonies are based upon not being victimized and does not need treatment.
Moultrie - Mandatory Restitution Act: court is requesting restitution analysis. Jury has made determination. This session is not based on witness’s decision. It is victim’s responsibility to consent to diagnosis and treatment.
Judge - Your response. (To defense.)
Defense - Don’t know from jury verdict which victim has been victimized. This court preceding will determine what they require.
Moultrie - Individuals as victims of molestation the decision has been made regarding their treatment and diagnosis.
Dr. Richard Laurence Elliott is being sworn in to take stand.
Moultrie - Questioning regarding expertise in psychiatric treatment of physical and ______ abuse.
Defense - Made a statement in response to Moultrie question to witness on stand.
Moultrie - State your name.
Elliott - Richard Laurence Elliott.
Moultrie - Specialty in medicine?
Elliott - Psychiatry, neurology, stated other specialties.
Moultrie - State your background.
Elliott - Studied medicine at the University of Wisconsin. Two years in the army, one year of fellowship, one year in Chicago and certified in certain areas.
Moultrie - Where licensed?
Elliott - Active license in several other states and in Georgia.
Moultrie - Give brief summary of publications.
Elliott - Interest in chronically mental illness. Clinical cases, depression, etc.
Moultrie - Duties as professor and psychiatrist at Mercer University.
Elliott - Teach medical students and some physicians. Have small private practice at Mercer University.
Judge - That’s sufficient.
Moultrie - Dr. Elliott diagnosis of paperwork on physical and _____ abuse.
Elliott - Did not perform personal exams.
Moultrie - Experience process.
Elliott - After requiring requested documents, review literature to help in understanding impact.
Moultrie - Two exhibits of psychiatric effects and two treatment needs.
Judge - Any objections.
Defense - No.
(Examining exhibits)
Moultrie approaches bench.
Moultrie - Begin with exhibit one psychiatric effect. Outline for court key findings.
Elliott - First findings: Not all victims are symptomatic 2/3 or 3 quarters are symptomatic. Second findings: No symptoms how response is personal. Third findings: Certain risk factors and how well respond. (Rebuttal given at end about this statement the psychiatry gave)
Moultrie - Did you review findings?
Elliot - Indicate someone who will suffer later. Continuing symptoms: threats, penetration, does poorly. Authority abuse more psychiatric problems, less family support and does poorly.
Moultrie - Did assess symptoms. One is to see under circumstances.
Elliott - Posttraumatic syndrome. Avoid personal suffering trauma. Likely to experience nightmares. Not same level of feelings, sleep problems, anxiety and have problems. Not same love and tenderness. Unworthy of relationships. Comparing age and adult life. Poorly in school. Behavior. Precocious activity with someone else younger.
Moultrie - Provided court with idea of ___ abuse. What factors make recovery poor?
Elliott - One or several abuse. Recovery is a year with no expected symptoms. Complicated factor will be longer to recovery. Preceding is constant reminder will prolong recovery. Parent’s belief - child’s damage and recovery difficult for victim. People may get a lot worse with recovery. Community blame victim make hard to recovery.
Moultrie - Findings in ____ abuse case?
Elliott - One therapy will work no single therapy. Becoming aggressive, precocious. Depression and anxiety is easy to treat. Sleep disturbance. Help with getting sleep. Help with symptoms through medicating because rapid kind of response. Group settings help with not feeling isolated. Shared concern and coping strategies. Belief abuse creates thought patterns of self-blame. Develop attitudes to avoid situation and develop trusting relationship. Other sources of support to be shared with others.
Moultrie - Able to quantify outcomes?
Elliott - No. Although 12 or so months victims may respond. No evidence.
Moultrie - Literature and experience applied in training assessing victims in this case.
Elliott - Reviewed synopsis and looked at reports.
Moultrie - How was helpful?
Elliott - Nature of abuse and relationship. Description of abuse and others talked about.
Moultrie - Prepare documents?
Elliott - Yes.
Moultrie - Treatment needs and consideration regarding cost.
Elliott - Estimated costs. Help where numbers come from hasn’t been done.
Moultrie - Expected cost estimate.
Elliott - Went through first few lines. Estimated cost based on geographical variations. Only six victims has been identified. One treatment episode using medication cost $150.00 and about $250.00 per episode per victim. Over twenty years six and ten victims cost approximately $50,000.00. Cost could go up if suffering is severe. Victim denied abuse. Charge for assessment no treatment cost. Anticipating as victim go through change. Needs will change. Concerns in marriage for victim. Estimated services victim might become depressed and hospital cost is $25,000.00. Picked number approximately $100,000.00 for _____ disease.
Moultrie - Individual assessment exhibit two.
Elliott - Taken from documents provided. Pulled out factors needed. Khalid 22 year old male has been abused since 13. Born on York property and he was the father who was at the right hand during his birth. Powerful figure. Regarding _____ sex, _____ sex was told to bring another boy. Feel some guilt. Being punished for not having _____. Psychiatric cost $5,500. Template used.
Moultrie - What does template mean to devise figure.
Elliott - Did not perform personal diagnosis had to form something. Average figure without physical evaluation for year followed by monthly and services model applied to many victims.
Moultrie - Number conservative?
Conversation between Moultrie and Dr. Elliott is regarding evaluation and cost of each victim is $23,596.00 and total cost is $19,000.00 and $550,000.00.
Moultrie - Ask to approach bench. (Defense and Moultrie)
Moultrie - Editing provided.
Elliott - Reviewed two. Sixteen year olds denial of abuse. Subsequent chlmydia without abuse. See York as authority figure and wants more psychiatric therapy. Different services. Victim is 22 year old and education is a concern.
Moultrie - Cost?
Elliott - $23, 596 services.
Moultrie - Hasna Evans was 17 years old.
Elliott - Regarding services of victims has not been abused. $2,250 cost.
Moultrie - Hasna.
Elliott - Denied abuse. Recommendations of services is $2,250.
Moultrie - Delora Crisna Hardin?
Elliott - 16 years old and abuse began at 5 years old and was raised on property. Had to beg for food, violence, and absence from school. Now living in residence facility. Hospitalized. Estimated cost $43,050.00.
Moultrie - Johnson is 14 years old.
Elliott - Denied abuse. Says York is father to everyone. Cried when York was arrested. Treatment needs. $23,596.
Moultrie - Safai Leroche is 17 years old.
Elliott - Report types of abuse. No motherly support. Live in fear and ostracized. Born in it and told York is God. Estimated cost.
Moultrie - Abdul Salaam Leroche.
Elliott - Name different types of abuse.
Judge - Regarding services.
Moultrie - Total?
Elliott - $23, 596.00.
Moultrie - Nicole Lopez.
Elliott - Depression, thoughts of suicide. $23,596.00. Most conservative.
Moultrie - Hannah Merit.
Elliott - 17 years old denied abuse. Witness saw her being abused. $2,750.00.
Moultrie - Victims denied ______ abuse.
Elliott - Camra Muhummad is 21 years old and 16 at time of abuse. Gave birth to 2 daughters. Hungry worked through night. Nightmares. $23,596.00. Symptoms, depression, nightmares, fear and had a child guilt.
Court Restitution
9:30AM - Chief Black Thunderbird “Eagle” escorted into courtroom.
9:35AM - Judge C. Ashley Royal enters and court comes to order.
(Keep in mind these notes are shorthand formatted and not word for word verbatim conversations. Thank you.)
Judge - Are you all ready for proceeding? (To lawyers)
Lawyers - Yes your honor.
(Government prepare)
Moultrie - My witness has one exhibit.
Judge - Asked defense if they seen exhibit.
Defense - They answered yes.
Moultrie - Review Dr. Elliott’s credentials and expertise regarding physical, mental and _____ abuse.
Defense - Clarification of credentials.
Moultrie - Psychiatry in diagnosis of physical, mental and ______ abuse.
(Preparation)
Judge - Are you going to have one witness?
Moultrie - Yes.
As we wait. Discussing with court regarding witness assumption. That they are not witnesses. Interest bearing account will be set up. Fruitless to state what happened at trial regarding witness.
Defense - Witnesses testimonies are based upon not being victimized and does not need treatment.
Moultrie - Mandatory Restitution Act: court is requesting restitution analysis. Jury has made determination. This session is not based on witness’s decision. It is victim’s responsibility to consent to diagnosis and treatment.
Judge - Your response. (To defense.)
Defense - Don’t know from jury verdict which victim has been victimized. This court preceding will determine what they require.
Moultrie - Individuals as victims of molestation the decision has been made regarding their treatment and diagnosis.
Dr. Richard Laurence Elliott is being sworn in to take stand.
Moultrie - Questioning regarding expertise in psychiatric treatment of physical and ______ abuse.
Defense - Made a statement in response to Moultrie question to witness on stand.
Moultrie - State your name.
Elliott - Richard Laurence Elliott.
Moultrie - Specialty in medicine?
Elliott - Psychiatry, neurology, stated other specialties.
Moultrie - State your background.
Elliott - Studied medicine at the University of Wisconsin. Two years in the army, one year of fellowship, one year in Chicago and certified in certain areas.
Moultrie - Where licensed?
Elliott - Active license in several other states and in Georgia.
Moultrie - Give brief summary of publications.
Elliott - Interest in chronically mental illness. Clinical cases, depression, etc.
Moultrie - Duties as professor and psychiatrist at Mercer University.
Elliott - Teach medical students and some physicians. Have small private practice at Mercer University.
Judge - That’s sufficient.
Moultrie - Dr. Elliott diagnosis of paperwork on physical and _____ abuse.
Elliott - Did not perform personal exams.
Moultrie - Experience process.
Elliott - After requiring requested documents, review literature to help in understanding impact.
Moultrie - Two exhibits of psychiatric effects and two treatment needs.
Judge - Any objections.
Defense - No.
(Examining exhibits)
Moultrie approaches bench.
Moultrie - Begin with exhibit one psychiatric effect. Outline for court key findings.
Elliott - First findings: Not all victims are symptomatic 2/3 or 3 quarters are symptomatic. Second findings: No symptoms how response is personal. Third findings: Certain risk factors and how well respond. (Rebuttal given at end about this statement the psychiatry gave)
Moultrie - Did you review findings?
Elliot - Indicate someone who will suffer later. Continuing symptoms: threats, penetration, does poorly. Authority abuse more psychiatric problems, less family support and does poorly.
Moultrie - Did assess symptoms. One is to see under circumstances.
Elliott - Posttraumatic syndrome. Avoid personal suffering trauma. Likely to experience nightmares. Not same level of feelings, sleep problems, anxiety and have problems. Not same love and tenderness. Unworthy of relationships. Comparing age and adult life. Poorly in school. Behavior. Precocious activity with someone else younger.
Moultrie - Provided court with idea of ___ abuse. What factors make recovery poor?
Elliott - One or several abuse. Recovery is a year with no expected symptoms. Complicated factor will be longer to recovery. Preceding is constant reminder will prolong recovery. Parent’s belief - child’s damage and recovery difficult for victim. People may get a lot worse with recovery. Community blame victim make hard to recovery.
Moultrie - Findings in ____ abuse case?
Elliott - One therapy will work no single therapy. Becoming aggressive, precocious. Depression and anxiety is easy to treat. Sleep disturbance. Help with getting sleep. Help with symptoms through medicating because rapid kind of response. Group settings help with not feeling isolated. Shared concern and coping strategies. Belief abuse creates thought patterns of self-blame. Develop attitudes to avoid situation and develop trusting relationship. Other sources of support to be shared with others.
Moultrie - Able to quantify outcomes?
Elliott - No. Although 12 or so months victims may respond. No evidence.
Moultrie - Literature and experience applied in training assessing victims in this case.
Elliott - Reviewed synopsis and looked at reports.
Moultrie - How was helpful?
Elliott - Nature of abuse and relationship. Description of abuse and others talked about.
Moultrie - Prepare documents?
Elliott - Yes.
Moultrie - Treatment needs and consideration regarding cost.
Elliott - Estimated costs. Help where numbers come from hasn’t been done.
Moultrie - Expected cost estimate.
Elliott - Went through first few lines. Estimated cost based on geographical variations. Only six victims has been identified. One treatment episode using medication cost $150.00 and about $250.00 per episode per victim. Over twenty years six and ten victims cost approximately $50,000.00. Cost could go up if suffering is severe. Victim denied abuse. Charge for assessment no treatment cost. Anticipating as victim go through change. Needs will change. Concerns in marriage for victim. Estimated services victim might become depressed and hospital cost is $25,000.00. Picked number approximately $100,000.00 for _____ disease.
Moultrie - Individual assessment exhibit two.
Elliott - Taken from documents provided. Pulled out factors needed. Khalid 22 year old male has been abused since 13. Born on York property and he was the father who was at the right hand during his birth. Powerful figure. Regarding _____ sex, _____ sex was told to bring another boy. Feel some guilt. Being punished for not having _____. Psychiatric cost $5,500. Template used.
Moultrie - What does template mean to devise figure.
Elliott - Did not perform personal diagnosis had to form something. Average figure without physical evaluation for year followed by monthly and services model applied to many victims.
Moultrie - Number conservative?
Conversation between Moultrie and Dr. Elliott is regarding evaluation and cost of each victim is $23,596.00 and total cost is $19,000.00 and $550,000.00.
Moultrie - Ask to approach bench. (Defense and Moultrie)
Moultrie - Editing provided.
Elliott - Reviewed two. Sixteen year olds denial of abuse. Subsequent chlmydia without abuse. See York as authority figure and wants more psychiatric therapy. Different services. Victim is 22 year old and education is a concern.
Moultrie - Cost?
Elliott - $23, 596 services.
Moultrie - Hasna Evans was 17 years old.
Elliott - Regarding services of victims has not been abused. $2,250 cost.
Moultrie - Hasna.
Elliott - Denied abuse. Recommendations of services is $2,250.
Moultrie - Delora Crisna Hardin?
Elliott - 16 years old and abuse began at 5 years old and was raised on property. Had to beg for food, violence, and absence from school. Now living in residence facility. Hospitalized. Estimated cost $43,050.00.
Moultrie - Johnson is 14 years old.
Elliott - Denied abuse. Says York is father to everyone. Cried when York was arrested. Treatment needs. $23,596.
Moultrie - Safai Leroche is 17 years old.
Elliott - Report types of abuse. No motherly support. Live in fear and ostracized. Born in it and told York is God. Estimated cost.
Moultrie - Abdul Salaam Leroche.
Elliott - Name different types of abuse.
Judge - Regarding services.
Moultrie - Total?
Elliott - $23, 596.00.
Moultrie - Nicole Lopez.
Elliott - Depression, thoughts of suicide. $23,596.00. Most conservative.
Moultrie - Hannah Merit.
Elliott - 17 years old denied abuse. Witness saw her being abused. $2,750.00.
Moultrie - Victims denied ______ abuse.
Elliott - Camra Muhummad is 21 years old and 16 at time of abuse. Gave birth to 2 daughters. Hungry worked through night. Nightmares. $23,596.00. Symptoms, depression, nightmares, fear and had a child guilt.